Friday, July 30, 2010

Prisoners' dilemma at the ping-pong table

At my workplace, we have at least one Ping Pong table on each of our floors. Next to each table we used to have a box with 4 rackets and a ball. People came, played, and then left the rackets in the box. Since not everybody was careful with them, the rackets we found were usually in bad shape, which was rather disconcerting. Some smart guy found a solution; the next time he found a racket that was relatively new, he didn't place it back in the box but instead he took it back with him, and it's possible that he (involuntarily) prompted his mates to do likewise.

So now the situation is a classic tragedy of commons. If you find a racket in the box, you can slink away with it or be a saint and put it back in the box. If you nick it, you'll probably get to play whenever you feel like. Keep it back and you'll probably never see it again. So everybody claims any racket they find. They don't do it out of malice, but simply because it is a rational being's dominant strategy. Consequently, people like me who've not (yet) shoplifted a racket never get to play. At least, not on a whim.

What got me thinking is that the people in this "experiment" (I call it that because it makes me less frustrated) are some of the most pampered folks in this country. They earn enough to satisfy their needs, wants and more, and could easily afford a racket or thousand, and our office is arguably one of the best workplaces around. If this is an indication of how highly educated, privileged people instinctively treat their shared resources, then the outlook for humanity must be rather bleak.


Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

*sigh* - another one of the situations that proves, that certain basic values like 'being conscientious'; 'civic' sense; 'respecting public property' etc has absolutely NO connection to the 'lack of education' and/or 'low income levels/poverty.'

vineet said...

Ridiculous! OK now if you buy one and start playing with it, what if people assume that you had taken one home earlier!? May be that is the question of a lot of people!

@Sats: Education cannot be an answer to everything but imagine a group of uneducated people near the ping pong table everyday in the office. I'm sure that things go worse. At least I can't be that sure otherwise...:)

Shreeni said...

I should remember not to read your blogs while drinking beverages, specially the kind which can spoil my keyboard or mouse or monitor or God forbid, the laptop itself. :-)

BTW, this kind of thing doesn't seem to happen where the overwhelming spirit is that of survival. Take seats in a train or bus. In India, somebody is pushing or prodding their way to a seat as soon as the current resident is shuffling out. But in Singapore, nobody does that. Often seats are left empty while people are still standing.

But it is probably just one anecdotal evidence. I might be wrong.